Results (R)
2R2 Comparing Results to Other Institutions
NSSE data for Student Engagement indicates
that first-year students scored lower than expected on the level of academic challenge, active and collaborative learning, and student-faculty interaction, and higher than expected on the benchmarks of enriching educational experiences and supportive campus environment. Western seniors scored higher than expected on the benchmarks of student-faculty interaction and enriching educational experiences, but lower than expected on level of academic challenge, active and collaborative learning, and supportive campus environment.
Communicating Quality is unique to the mission, vision, and values of Western. Peer institutions have marketing and public relations functions, but finding comparable benchmarks is challenging.
Visits to other institutions and on-site project assessment indicate the Banner Gold implementation project has been successful. Each module was installed on time, within budget, and is being monitored for functionality.
Figure 2.5 Freshman results, including NSSE 2004
Dimension One: Philosophy |
Significant evidence supports Western’s claim that it takes an intentional approach to meeting the needs of first-year students.
-
Implementation of Western’s mission, vision, goals, and Strategic Plan
-
Positive student evaluations of Freshman Interest Groups (FIGs). Students note the quality of interaction and accomplishment of instructional goals.
-
First ranking within comparison group for the following: priority of first-year student success, comprehensive approach to helping first-year students succeed, and a coherent approach to helping first-year students succeed.
-
Increased student participation in Griffon Edge
-
Better-than-predicted response in enriching educational experiences and supportive campus environment
|
Dimension Two: Organization |
Western has appropriate administrative structure and programming to address the needs of first-year students.
-
Registration and Orientation Program, Griffon Edge
-
Student Services Office
-
Intensive Academic Advising Student Success Seminars
-
Learning Communities
-
Western Warm-up and Student Government Association Week
-
S.T.A.R. Peer Advisement Program
-
Honors Program
-
Minority Initiatives/Achievement Program
-
Program for Athletes’ Scholastic Success
-
First ranking among the seven institutions in the comparison group on priority of first-year student success, comprehensive approach to helping first-year students succeed, and a coherent approach to helping first-year students succeed
|
Dimension Three: Transitions |
Western works to improve the transition of first-year students.
-
Student Convocation
-
Debt management tools
-
Academic policies
-
Academic advising
-
Developmental courses
-
Student success activities
-
Student Orientation
-
Griffon Edge activities
-
Ranks third in the comparison group of seven institutions in helping students transition.
First ranking among the comparison group of seven in conveying to new students the sense that, if they make the effort, they can succeed.
|
Dimension Four: Faculty |
Western students rank faculty high on teaching, faculty development, and involvement with the first year.
-
Student ratings of relationships with faculty members at 5.49 on a scale of one to seven.
-
Statistically higher rating than the comparison group of six institutions and the comparison group of all institutions completing the survey on importance placed on the first year, teaching, and faculty development.
-
Statistically higher score compared to six institutions on supporting faculty work with all students.
|
Dimension Five: All Students
|
Western provides services to students deciding on a major.
-
Of respondents, 84 percent reporting that Western provided the support needed to help students succeed academically.
-
Significantly higher scores than American Democracy Project schools (ADP) on helping students cope with non-academic responsibilities and providing support to help students succeed academically.
-
Academic advising system that provides extensive contact with a faculty advisor
-
Career Services Office
-
Counseling Center
-
Financial Aid Office
-
Center for Multicultural Education
-
Honors Program
-
Center for Academic Support
-
Residential Life Programming
|
Dimension Six: Engagement |
Western provides a culture of engagement and encourages students to participate in service.
-
Service opportunities for students, faculty, and staff identified and communicated.
-
Citizen-scholar model Introduced during student orientation.
-
Active-learning approaches used in first-year courses.
-
Students, faculty, and staff participating in community service.
|
Dimension Seven: Diversity |
Western students encouraged to participate in multicultural learning experiences.
-
Significantly higher score than other baccalaureate-general institutions regarding students conversing with students of a different race or ethnicity.
-
Significantly higher score than the three comparison groups on encouraging contact among students from different economic, social, and racial or ethnic backgrounds and students understanding people of other racial and ethnic backgrounds.
|
Dimension Eight: Roles and Purposes |
Western communicates the roles and purpose of higher education to students.
-
Evaluation of Learning Communities
-
Evaluation of Advising System
-
New Student Convocation
-
Evaluation of General Education
-
New Student Orientation
-
NSSE
-
Faculty Survey
|
Dimension Nine: Improvement |
Western uses several sources of data to make improvements.
-
College Student Inventory Results
-
National Survey of Student Engagement Results
-
Placement in developmental courses
-
Developmental Education Committee
-
Assessment and Benchmarking Committee
-
Significantly higher score than the mean of the comparison group of six institutions and the comparison group of all institutions on using data to make improvements.
|
|